Cigar Aficionado Ratings

The Montecristo Toro Fresh Loc 4-Cigar Sampler is your golden opportunity to enjoy four of this historic brand’s most popular cigars. Nested inside each pack is one each, toro-sized Montecristo Classic Collection, Montecristo Nicaragua, Montecristo Platinum, and Montecristo White cigar. From mild to full-bodied, this sampler offers a variety of flavors that will please aficionados of all stripes.

In 2019, the Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro torpedo (6"x52) cigar received a 96-rating and the coveted #1 spot in Cigar Aficionado's Top 25 Cigars of the Year. Then in 2021, the Quattro Nicaragua Concerto Churchill (7"x50) cigar received a 93 rating and was ranked #14 in Cigar Aficionado's Top 25 Cigars of the Year. The Aging Room Quattro Fresh Loc 4-Cigar Sampler is your chance to get two (2) each of these award-winning cigars in one sealed-for-freshness pack. The Nicaragua was the first cigar in the Quattro portfolio to be made entirely of premium Nicaraguan tobacco, and it was the first Quattro cigar to be made outside of the Dominican Republic. This Nicaraguan puro sports a dark savory maduro wrapper. Rich notes of chocolate, earth, and cedar will greet your taste buds when you light up this potent but balanced cigar. And this must-have sampler is available at a wallet pleasing price. 

Tucked inside the Fonseca by My Father Cosacos, Tin of 5 are five corona-sized Nicaraguan versions of this storied brand. The Fonseca is a full-bodied premium cigar that is hand crafted at the Garcia Family Industrial Park factory, which is owned by My Father Cigars. This Nicaraguan puro sports an inviting red-hued, shade grown Corojo ’98 wrapper and delivers rich earthy and spicy flavors. The Fonseca brand is a century old brand that was originally founded in Cuba.

Now you can make a toast to Brick House, one of the oldest and most popular cigar brands in the world. The Brick House Bricktoberfest Beer Stein is a handsome glass beer mug that sports the iconic Brick House logo, and it is sure to become a collectible. Plus! This Brick House Bricktoberfest Beer Stein comes filled with 10 Brick House cigars for you to enjoy while you quaff down your favorite IPA or craft beer.

Our weekly staff picks are a favorite among our customers and now you can subscribe to receive a monthly sampler with a selection of the cigars picked by our expert staff! This is a 6-month subscription in which you will receive 6 amazing cigars (includes free shipping) picked by our staff including our staff review, specifications, and pairing suggestions. Samplers ship every month. Embark on a sensory experience curated by our cigar experts! This is a great gift for yourself or your loved ones! When do the samplers ship every month? The samplers ship between the second and third week of every month. Will I be charged automatically every six months? Yes, your credit card will be charged semi-annually. Every month, you will receive an email confirmation with the prepaid sampler order and a second email with your tracking information. If you need to change your credit card on the account, please contact us. How do I cancel my subscription? You may cancel your subscription at any time, just email us. What will I receive with my subscription? You will receive 6 cigars curated by our Neptune staff, with a value well over the price. You will also receive a link to the reviews and pairing suggestion for each of the cigars. Who is the staff? The staff that curates the sampler is comprised of our expert tobacconists that work in our brick and mortar stores. We know that this will be an excellent way for you to expand your horizons when it comes to finding new and exciting cigars!

The Macanudo Inspirado Taster 5-Cigar Sampler is perfect for aficionados who enjoy a more contemporary smoke or the cigar lover who is looking for a break from the traditional. Tucked inside each sealed-for-freshness pack are one each, toro-sized Inspirado Black, Inspirado Green, Inspirado Orange, Inspirado Red, and Inspirado White. Each handmade cigar is individually wrapped in cellophane.