The Blind Man's Bluff by Caldwell is a medium-bodied Honduran cigar which features an oily Ecuadorian Habano wrapper on top of a Honduran Criollo binder and premium Dominican and Honduran filler. Notes of cedar, pepper and bread greet your palate throughout, and with the top-notch craftsmanship you expect from Caldwell, there's no reason this solid cigar shouldn't find a regular home in your humidor.
940Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips tomorrow ·
Single
$13.65
$12.30$13.65
$1.35
60Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
780Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
860Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips tomorrow ·
Single
$12.34
$11.15$12.34
$1.19
55Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
Combined with decades of family tradition and Cuban expertise, this 5-cigar sampler reflects why the Dominican Republic remains unique among cigar regions. The DR became a global leader in premium cigars after the Cuban trade embargo, when skilled growers and rollers brought their craft to its fertile valleys. The Cibao Valley’s rich, fertile soil rivals Cuba’s Vuelta Abajo, while stable sun and rainfall create reliable harvests and even curing. Dominican tobaccos age beautifully, developing smooth complexity, and the country produces a wide range of leaf styles: from delicate fillers to bold wrappers.
Packaging
MSRP
Our price
You save
Smoke rings
Availability
Qty
Add to cart
Sampler
$61.43
$58.39$61.43
$3.04
290Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips tomorrow ·
Reviews across all sizes
4.51★★★★★★★★★★88 reviews
By criteria
Draw4.5
Appearance4.7
Burn4.4
Aroma4.4
Taste4.5
By stars
Ghassan Barry · Man's Magnum · Wed Nov 04
smooth medium cigar
Dugue JL · Man's Magnum · Sat Jan 31
Great cigar again by Caldwell! Nice mix of flavors. Complex smoke
Oliver H · Man's Toro · Sat Dec 27
This is my first Caldwell, and honestly, I didn’t know what to expect from this Blind Man’s Bluff. And I got bluffed! To me, this stick ranks among the most elegant cigars I’ve had so far, holding its own from foot to nub against some renowned Cuban cigars I’ve smoked. By elegance, I mean the consistency of the flavors delivered—cedar, toasted bread, a touch of hazelnut, and a pinch of pepper—along with a smooth profile all the way through. Construction, draw and burn were flawless. It’s a really easy, enjoyable smoke. I’ll definitely be keeping more of these in my humidor and trying other cigars from Caldwell.
Andrew Poulos · Man's Toro · Tue Oct 14
Great Cigar
Leila KABORE · Man's Magnum · Wed Oct 08
Good
Luis Silveira · Man's Magnum · Fri May 02
A great cigar with a solid construction and a very good overall performance. Recommended.
arash shekarriz · Man's Toro · Tue Aug 20
Not bad!
Eric Duczkowski · Man's Toro · Tue Apr 16
Great cigar and not many people talk about this of the line. The criollo binder with the habana wrapper really mingle for a unique flavor and experience. A lot of bread, creamy cedar and mild mild pepper. Not much pepper in terms of “burn” but more red pepper flavor with out the spice.
Joseph Ortiz · Man's Robusto · Fri Dec 08
Enjoyable stick, nothing earth moving
Simon Corkindale · Man's Magnum · Sun Aug 27
Big and badass, just how I like it. Smooth draw with a spicy soul. Enjoyed every puff
