The Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Edicion Diamente cigar was developed by AJ Fernandez and Rafael Nodal, two of the cigar industry’s most highly regarded cigar makers. Originally, the blend was supposed to be used for the Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Nicaragua, but AJ and Rafael felt that, like a diamond in the rough, the blend needed more time. So, they tweaked it until finally they released this fine Nicaraguan puro that features a lush maduro wrapper made of a hybrid-seed tobacco grown in Jalapa, Nicaragua. This awesome capa covers a criollo binder from Ometepe and a filler from Esteli. This expertly crafted cigar and its unique blend showcases the fine tobaccos that are grown in Nicaragua. It truly is a jewel of a cigar that is a joy to behold as it is to smoke.
★★★★★★★★★★4.73(6)Rated 92 by Cigar Insider · Sep 2023
Packaging
MSRP
Our price
You save
Smoke rings
Availability
Qty
Add to cart
Box of 10
$266.00
$239.95$266.00
$26.05
1,195Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips today ·
Single
$26.60
$23.95$26.60
$2.65
115Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
★★★★★★★★★★4.67(3)Rated 93 by Cigar Insider · Sep 2023
Packaging
MSRP
Our price
You save
Smoke rings
Availability
Qty
Add to cart
Box of 10
$256.60
$230.95$256.60
$25.65
1,150Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips today ·
Single
$25.66
$23.10$25.66
$2.56
115Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
★★★★★★★★★★4.20(7)Rated 91 by Cigar Insider · Sep 2023
Packaging
MSRP
Our price
You save
Smoke rings
Availability
Qty
Add to cart
Box of 10
$167.50
$150.95$167.50
$16.55
750Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips today ·
Single
$16.75
$15.10$16.75
$1.65
75Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
★★★★★★★★★★4.10(8)Rated 93 by Cigar Insider · Sep 2023
Packaging
MSRP
Our price
You save
Smoke rings
Availability
Qty
Add to cart
Box of 10
$252.80
$227.95$252.80
$24.85
1,135Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips today ·
Single
$25.28
$22.75$25.28
$2.53
110Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
★★★★★★★★★★4.55(4)Rated 92 by Cigar Aficionado · Sep 2023Rated 92 by Cigar Insider · Sep 2023
Packaging
MSRP
Our price
You save
Smoke rings
Availability
Qty
Add to cart
Box of 10
$233.20
$209.95$233.20
$23.25
1,045Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips today ·
Single
$23.32
$21.00$23.32
$2.32
105Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
★★★★★★★★★★4.73(9)Rated 90 by Cigar Insider · Sep 2023
Packaging
MSRP
Our price
You save
Smoke rings
Availability
Qty
Add to cart
Box of 10
$246.80
$222.95$246.80
$23.85
1,110Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips today ·
Single
$24.68
$22.25$24.68
$2.43
110Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
710Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
605Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works →
In stockShips today ·
Reviews across all sizes
4.44★★★★★★★★★★40 reviews
By criteria
Draw4.5
Appearance4.7
Burn4.5
Aroma4.3
Taste4.2
By stars
James Crow · Robusto · 08/23/2026
Firm construction, beautiful oily and silky smooth wrapper, open draw and even burn with no touchups needed. Medium bodied and very smooth with tons of rich, creamy blue-gray smoke output and flavors of woodsy cedar, black pepper spice and bittersweet dark chocolate. A very nice cigar!
Ralph Bassolino · Grande · 07/03/2026
A nice fat smoke…expertly constructed and a really balanced mix…a nice long quality smoke
Aaron · Toro · 04/17/2026
Big fan of the Toro
Francisco Torvisco · No. 2 · 01/20/2026
Great cigar that carries all the positives from the regular 1935 but at a more expensive price point.
Humberto Campo · Grande · 09/13/2025
Excellent cigar
Joseph Meyers · No. 2 · 08/10/2025
The profile is consistent in theme the whole way through, with just the respective intensities of each flavor varying throughout. Quite lovely though. Nuts, sweet spices, whole grain breads, a bit of wood, and a finish of a unique apple sweetness and pepper. Nuts and sweet and tart apple bread/pie are the biggest flavors. Medium the entire time. Burn got less reliable as the cigar went on. 93/100.
Joseph Meyers · Grande · 08/10/2025
The profile is consistent in theme the whole way through, with just the respective intensities of each flavor varying throughout. Quite lovely though. Nuts, sweet spices, whole grain breads, a bit of wood, and a finish of a unique apple sweetness and pepper. Nuts and sweet and tart apple bread/pie are the biggest flavors. Medium the entire time. Burn got less reliable as the cigar went on. 93/100.
Dominique Defoe · Toro · 03/03/2025
Bon cigare
Ben Janusch · No. 2 · 12/22/2024
You can tell where the tweaks were made to the original recipe. Where the 1935 was in your face, the Diamante sits next to you quietly and delivers a quality experience. Both are great for different situations. This one was a good coffee pairing. Would have liked a little more complexity.
Dr. Shawn Seitz · Doble Toro · 11/18/2024
An underwhelming cigar for the price. Not at all what I was hoping to experience. I’ll try letting them sit in my humidor for a couple of years and try again.