My Father The Judge Grand Robusto 5" × 60
| Packaging | MSRP | Our price | You save | Smoke rings | Availability | Qty | Add to cart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Box of 20 | $239.40 | $26.60 | 1,195Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works → | Sold out | |||
| Single | $13.30 | $13.30 | — | 65Smoke Rings are the reward points you earn on every purchase — 5 rings per dollar, more as a Gold or Platinum member — and on every review of a cigar you bought from us. Redeem them any time in your account for premium cigars and accessories.How the program works → | Sold out |
Description
This cigar earned Cigar Aficionado's No. 1 Cigar of the Year in 2024. A medium to full-bodied smoke with deep notes of wood, leather, and spice. Its Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper drapes a Nicaraguan binder and filler. The My Father The Judge cigars are handmade in Nicaragua.
Specifications
- Cigar Shape
- Robusto
- Cigar Section
- Box-Pressed (Square)
- Cigar Length
- 5"
- Origin
- Nicaragua
- Cigar Ring Gauge
- 60
- Strength
- Full
- Wrapper Color
- Colorado Maduro
- Single Packaging
- Cellophane
- Rolling Type
- Handmade
- Cigar Manufacturer
- My Father Cigars
- Cigar Wrapper
- Ecuadorian Sumatra-Seed
- Cigar Binder
- Nicaragua
User ratings & reviews
By criteria
By stars
- 5.00
Top cigar, fantastic draw , lots of smoke, burn spot on, notes of little spice , burnt toast, tea, you won’t be disappointed with this one
Russell D. · 11/10/2026 - 5.00
Perfect
Mohammed A. · 10/28/2026 - 5.00
Maybe not 98 rating but it's 100% amazing and worth it. Still would rate in the 90s. REALLY good full deep chocolate and earth. Candy bar at times.
Mike D. · 10/19/2026 - 5.00
Smoke this and you'll know why it won cigar of the year with a 98 point rating. It's a total chocolate bomb - my personal favorite tasting note in cigars. It's also packed with earthy, leathery notes and a fig undertone. From start to finish it's a complex flavor journey. Definitely box worthy.
Robert C. · 10/09/2026 - 5.00
This is truly an amazing cigar and smoke, especially for the price.
Michael H. · 09/29/2026 - 4.80
Smooth flavorful flavorful
Ronald C. · 08/22/2026 - 5.00
My absolute favorite. Just perfection
Jon B. · 08/12/2026 - 5.00
??
rafael r. · 08/04/2026 - 4.20
Great cigar. You can see why it won awards. The size is chunky, but the flavor and strength are on full display. Must try.
Sam Y. · 07/25/2026 - 5.00
I bought this to try based on the Cigar Aficionado rating and honestly wasn't let down. Outstanding flavor and perfect construction. I like the size of the Grande Robusto as well, it just feels right. This was one of my favorite smokes of the year and will be purchasing more for sure!
Justin P. · 07/25/2026
